Milvus vs. Pinecone
Compare Milvus vs. Pinecone by the following set of capabilities. We want you to choose the best database for you, even if it’s not us.
Milvus vs. Pinecone on Scalability
Yes, for the Serverless tier.
Yes. At the component level (which provides more fine-grained scalability).
Yes, for the Serverless tier.
Dynamic segment placement
Static sharding
Milvus scalability
Regarding scalability, Milvus uses worker nodes for each type of action (components to handle connections, data nodes to handle ingestion, index nodes to index, and query nodes to search). Each node has its own assigned CPU and memory resources. Milvus can dynamically allocate new nodes to an action group, speeding up operations or reducing the number of nodes, thus freeing resources for other actions. Dynamically allocating nodes allows for easier scaling and resource planning and guarantees latency and throughput.
Pinecone
Pinecone supports the separation of compute and storage with their Serveless Tier.
For its POD-based clusters, Pinecone employs static sharding, which requires users to manually reshard data when scaling out the cluster.
Milvus vs. Pinecone on Functionality
Performance is the biggest challenge with vector databases as the number of unstructured data elements stored in a vector database grows into hundreds of millions or billions, and horizontal scaling across multiple nodes becomes paramount.
Furthermore, differences in insert rate, query rate, and underlying hardware may result in different application needs, making overall system tunability a mandatory feature for vector databases.
Yes, with limited roles (only Org Owner & members are supported)
Yes (DiskANN)
Available with the Pinecone S1 solution only
Yes. Sparse & Dense Vectors and Scalar filtering.
Yes. Sparse & Dense Vectors and Scalar filtering.
Yes. Users cans organizes data into namespaces and should aware that there are a limited number of namespaces available. Please consult with Pinecone on the limitations.
Closed source Index (proprietary)
Milvus functionality
- Milvus supports multiple in-memory indexes and table-level partitions results in the high performance required for real-time information retrieval systems.
- RBAC support is a requirement for enterprise-grade applications.
- In regards to partitions, by limiting searches to one or several subsets of the database, partitions can provide a more efficient way to filter data compared to static sharding, which can introduce bottlenecks and require re-sharding as data grows beyond server capacity. Partitions are a great way to manage your data by grouping it into subsets based on categories or time ranges. This can help you to easily filter and search through large amounts of data, without having to search through the entire database every time.
- No single Index type can fit all use cases since each use case will have different tradeoffs With more index types supported, you have more flexibility to find the balance between accuracy, performance and cost.
Pinecone
RBAC is not enough for large organizations. Storage optimized (S1 ) has some performance challenges and can only get 10-50 QPS. The number of namespaces is limited and users should be careful when using metadata filtering as a way around this limitation as it will have a big impact on performance. Furthermore, data isolation is not available with this approach.
Milvus vs. Pinecone on Purpose-built
What’s your vector database for?
A vector database is a fully managed solution for storing, indexing, and searching across a massive dataset of unstructured data that leverages the power of embeddings from machine learning models. A vector database should have the following features:
- Scalability and tunability
- Multi-tenancy and data isolation
- A complete suite of APIs
- An intuitive user interface/administrative console
Milvus vs. Pinecone: what’s right for me?
Milvus
Milvus is a fully open source and independent project, maintained by a number of companies and individuals, some of whom also offer commercial services and support. Graduate of LF AI Data. License: Apache-2.0 license
Pinecone
Pinecone is a managed, cloud-native vector database.
SaaS
